Thursday, October 18, 2007

The Situationist International and its Legacies

Guy Debord

“Toward a Situationist International” describes the purpose of creating the construction of situations and transforming them into a higher, more passionate nature. The situationists were a group of artists who opposed the reality of the capitalist world. They wanted to make a change in the way that life was being lived in their society, so they set up alternatives to the modern ways of life. They felt as though society had become a realm of actors and spectators and that the creativity of individuals was fleeting; so they developed an intervention that would fuse together the material setting of life and the behaviors that inhabit it. The attempt was to create the idea of unitary urbanism which would use artistic techniques in cooperation with the environment. The plan was to create experimental cities in which each city will contain “districts”. Each of the districts would represent a single emotion which a subject would consciously expose themselves to.

Within the capitalist society, there was a great division between the upper class and the lower class which corresponded to the roles people played as producer and consumer. Those who could afford the products were considered the consumers; yet those who produced the products could not afford to be the consumers. There was a great separation in society which not only separated the classes but it alienated many individuals. The process of alienation begins with the fact that the individuals producing a product only produced a specific part of the product; a single individual was no longer responsible for creating the entire product. The new idea of specialized work detached the producer from the product and alienated the individual from the product and also alienated the worker from other individuals. An interesting visual example which portrays the idea of specialized work is the Charlie Chaplin film “Modern Times”, in which we see an individual who is taken over by the repetitiveness of his specialized job that he continues the motion of his work even when he goes on break. The idea here is that the individual is turned into a machine and dehumanized which further alienates him from other individuals. The situationists wanted to change this fact by creating their own alternative to the capitalist society. They wanted to disrupt the order of modern society and pose ways of thinking that were alternative and also liberating for the individual.

Modern Times Charlie Chaplin - Video Clips.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wBIov_CSqyI

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IjarLbD9r30

Early Avant-Garde

Peter Bürger

Peter Bürger suggests that the autonomy of art is defined as “art’s independence from society.” The autonomy of art is a characteristic which describes something real. Within Bourgeois society the division of labor became the reason for the separation of the producer from the product; but in the case of the artist, their products were seen as something special and important because the artist was completely involved in every aspect of the creation of the work. Interests in artistic techniques such as composition and colour are the reasons for the new social position of the artist, which is a result of the growth in commissioned art. The new social position of the artist allows him to have more freedom in what he visually creates because it is the uniqueness of the techniques of an artist which separates himself from others and makes him individual. The uniqueness and individuality of the artist is what drives the art market to become what it has today. Artists are recognized for their unique style and collectors begin to buy art because of the status of a particular artist; commissioned work is much a thing of the past, and now the artist has the freedom to create what he pleases instead of being instructed to create a specific work.

The Politics of Publicity

Jürgen Habermas

Jürgen Hebermas defines the concept of the public sphere to be a realm of our social life in which public opinion can be formed. It is the place where individuals come together with their own ideas in conversation with one another to form a public body. He says that “Citizens behave as a public body when they confer in an unrestricted fashion – that is, with the guarantee of freedom of assembly and association and the freedom to express and publish their opinions – about matters of general interest.” This idea of freedom of expression in the public format is very relevant in today’s society. We see this happen in our everyday lives. Newspapers, magazines, television and radio all help to facilitate in creating the modern day public sphere. For instance, there are many television shows which incorporate elements of the idea of the public sphere into the program itself. Shows like Nancy Grace on CNN discuss issues in the media such as criminal trials, political events and world issues at hand. The show helps to facilitate the atmosphere of the public sphere because it allows for many different viewpoints on a situation. Guests who appear on the show are allowed to talk freely and openly about their opinions and there are usually several different viewpoints about a situation that are presented to the public; in which case everyone watching the show will be able to identify with or agree with at least one viewpoint. Another example of a television show representing the public sphere is a show called “The View”. This show creates an interesting little niche for itself in that in represents the female perspective on certain issues. Throughout history, the public sphere has been dominated by male figures. What this show allows for is a realm for the women of the world to come together to form a public opinion that suits their needs. The idea of the show is that each of the female hosts represents a certain type of woman that exists in modern society; they each have different opinions, characters, nationalities and political backgrounds. At the beginning of each show, the ladies gather around a table to discuss what they call “Hot Topics”, which consist of topics ranging from political issues, top news stories and even celebrity gossip. The topic is thrown on the table for discussion where each of the ladies is free to voice their opinion about a topic. Not only does this mimic the ideas of the public sphere, but it introduces a new idea about the public sphere where women are now able to voice their opinion freely; and there becomes an alternate public sphere to that which is dominated by male figures.

The idea of the public sphere is what enables activist art to take place. Individuals are able to freely voice their opinion about certain issues of the world and make it known to the masses. Media outlets such as television and advertising make it possible for ideas to be spread to the masses. Without the technological advancements of the media, it would be far more difficult to reach out to as many people as it allows us to in today’s world. The media today can be accessed by millions of people around the globe within seconds. Breaking news events and stories can be broadcasted within seconds, simultaneously to countries all across the world; of course the invention of the internet makes this idea very possible and completely accessible.

Critical Theories of Cultural Production

Theodor Adorno and Max Horkheimer

The Marxist idea of alienation continues in Adorno and Horkheimer’s article about mass deception. The reality that individuals within capitalist societies are alienated from the product also leads to the de-skilling of workers and makes them dumb. Adorno’s argument is that in a capitalist society there is no such thing as the individual. We are fooled into believing we are unique but the fact of the matter is, is that we are all controlled by the absolute power of capitalism. The media, such as television, films, radio and magazines are a tool used by the culture industry to control and persuade the opinions of the mass population. The media is an ingenious way of producing propaganda and it creates the tension or the confusion in distinguishing the real world from the illusory world.

The Culture industry is also a way of distinguishing differences in classes by classifying, organizing and labeling consumers based on the products they can afford or choose to buy. For example, there are many different types of magazines which gear to a certain personality as well as fit into different price ranges. This difference in content and cost is what distinguishes one consumer of a certain magazine from the other. Another example is in the fashion industry. There are the famous brand names, whose fashions are ridiculously expensive and geared toward an upper class market. For the majority of the public, these items are unattainable; so there is a market created specifically for them with no name designers. The individuals who can afford the brand name products are awarded with the “prestige” of wearing the designer names on their sleeves (quite literally).

Nina Felshin "But is it Art?"

Nina Felshin


Nina Felshin’s article But is it Art?, explains the world of activist art. She says that it is artwork in which the artists incorporate political activist ideas mixed with artistic practices. Many of the artists who emerged as activist artists did so throughout the mid 1970’s until the 1990’s and continuing on until present day. Many of the artists work dealt with sociopolitical issues, but what set activist art apart from political art is the way in which the artworks are presented to us. The content remains the same or at least very similar in both activist and political art, but it is the methods used in activist art which sets it apart from political art. In many cases activist art often includes public participation; encouraging people to participate as a whole and to and come together to make a difference in the world. These artists felt that public participation would help make a difference in effecting social change; it would also help make many people aware of the issues at hand. Political art on the other hand simply brought attention to the issues; they had no intention of making a difference about the problems at hand.

Some of the issues that activist art shed light on were issues of homelessness, the AIDS crisis, the environment, violence against women, racism, sexism, etc. To make these issues apparent to the public, activist artists used the media and technology; which was helpful in bringing the message to the masses. Artists used such things as billboard signs, subway and newspaper advertising as a method of delivering their messages. Using the media gave these artists a great advantage. Their messages of sociopolitical concerns were able to reach the masses and therefore many people were able to become informed about these important issues. This method of employing their art is very important to the purpose of activist art. Just like the genres title suggests, activist art is meant to bring forth action; it is not simply about bringing awareness to an issue, but rather it is about bringing forth some kind of change or action to the situation. Like Felshin describes in the article, activist art is about the process, rather then the product or object. The process involves the participation of the public. It is not enough to simply have an activist piece of artwork showcased in a small gallery, where only a limited number of people will see it. For example, a poster or advertisement in a subway is more likely to be viewed by thousands of people, rather then a painting in a small gallery downtown. In order for the artwork to bring forth some kind of change, it must reach as many people as possible; and what better way then to send the message through the media. In today’s world we are completely surrounded and even at times suffocated by the effects of the media, which makes it a great platform to present ideas about pressing issues in society. Activist art is effective because of the simple fact that its main goal is to bring awareness to as many people as possible.